PHOs warn free GP visits could worsen access to care

November 4, 2026
By
Arataki PHO and Community Care PHO

New GenPro survey finds just 14% of general practice owners support Labour's three free GP visits policy, as clinical leaders warn that without more clinicians, those with the greatest health needs could miss out.

Clinical leaders from Arataki PHO and Community Care PHO say the latest GenPro survey reinforces concerns that free GP visits cannot be delivered without significant investment in workforce capacity.

The survey of 132 general practice owners found just 14% supported Labour's proposal for three free GP visits annually.

"It's encouraging to see political parties putting primary care at the centre of this election," said Jess White, Head of Arataki PHO and Community Care PHO. "We all want healthcare to be more affordable, but we need the workforce to deliver it."

"We support making primary care more accessible," said Dr Richard Dales, Clinical Director for Arataki PHO and Community Care PHO. "But making visits free won't help if there's no one available to see you."

Demand will rise

Primary care is already stretched. In the 2024/25 New Zealand Health Survey, around one in four adults and one in five children reported that waiting too long for an appointment was a barrier to seeing a GP.

When free visits were extended to under-14s in 2015, GP visits for that age group rose by almost 17%. With New Zealanders already making 13 to 14 million GP visits annually, a proportional increase in demand across the population would mean more than 2 million additional appointments each year.

Labour's own modelling reflects the scale of the challenge, proposing to free up 4.5 million GP appointments annually through phone triage, technology, long-term condition support and clinic expansion.

The capacity isn't there to free up

Across Arataki PHO and Community Care PHO, supporting practices caring for around 450,000 enrolled patients, Labour's proposed 4.5 million appointments equates to thousands of additional appointments every week on a population-proportionate basis.

"Our practices are already doing much of this work," said Jess White. "Clinical phone triage, nurse-led long-term condition care, multidisciplinary teams and AI tools are already embedded across many practices. The efficiencies are already being reinvested in patient care.

"But phone triage doesn't run itself. Every call requires a healthcare professional. Delivering the proposed volumes would require hundreds of additional healthcare workers nationally."

"Technology absolutely has a role to play, but we can't count efficiencies already being delivered as new capacity," said Jess White.

"Across our PHOs, we're talking about the equivalent of dozens of additional full-time GPs and nurses," said Dr Dales. "With today's workforce, we simply cannot deliver it. Free visits are due to start in July 2028, but it takes the best part of a decade to train a GP. The doctors we'd need should already be in training, and they aren't."

Those with the greatest need could miss out

Approximately 50% of general practices nationally report GP vacancies, one in four are not accepting new enrolments and hundreds of thousands of New Zealanders remain unenrolled with a GP.

Labour's proposal links free visits to a patient's enrolled practice, raising concerns about those already unable to enrol.

"Cost is a significant barrier, but a free appointment only makes a difference if people can actually get one," said Dr Dales.

"When appointments are scarce, those who can book quickly, are comfortable with technology and have flexible jobs may have an advantage. Those at greatest risk of missing out are Māori, Pacific peoples, rural communities, disabled people and those experiencing socioeconomic disadvantage.

"As PHOs, we already use flexible funding to help priority populations struggling with appointment costs. Targeted support works. Equity has to be designed in from the start."

Invest in the workforce before increasing demand

The GenPro survey found 93% supported directing more health funding towards primary care, 86% backed ACT's proposed additional $100 million annually for general practice and 71% supported easier registration for overseas-trained doctors.

"These findings send a clear message to every political party," said Jess White. "General practice wants more investment, more clinicians and better access for patients. We should absolutely aspire to make healthcare more affordable, but promising free appointments without the workforce to deliver them risks making access harder for those who need it most."

Arataki PHO and Community Care PHO recommend five foundations for expanding free GP visits:

  • Targeted and phased access: Prioritise the estimated 650,000 New Zealanders who struggle to afford primary care, expanding as capacity grows.
  • Workforce before demand: Link implementation to demonstrated clinical capacity, not a fixed start date.
  • A funded workforce plan: Increase training places, streamline overseas recruitment and invest in multidisciplinary teams.
  • Fully funded visits: Fund appointments at the true cost of care, independently determined and adjusted annually.
  • Support enrolment: Ensure New Zealanders without an enrolled GP can benefit from improved access.

"Free doesn't automatically mean fair," said Dr Dales. "The measure of a successful policy isn't how many free appointments are promised. It's whether the New Zealanders who need healthcare can actually access it, when they need it."

‍